Since I got my new HTC Droid Eris, I have been comparing two different plugins to make my WordPress sites more mobile friendly – WordPress Mobile Pack and WPtouch iPhone Theme. Both get the job done effectively – it is just a matter of whether you are looking for something simple or something with a lot of features.
WordPress Mobile Pack – Simplicity
WordPress Plugin Site ~ Plugin Homepage
WordPress Mobile Pack was the first plugin I discovered while surfing another WordPress blog on my Droid. It basically allows you to setup your blog in a mobile format with four basic theme colors (black, red, blue, and green). Here is what my Dofollow resource site looks like on the Droid using WordPress Mobile Pack.
Homepage using WordPress Mobile Pack
Single Post using WordPress Mobile Pack
Post Footer using WordPress Mobile Pack
Post Comment Form using WordPress Mobile Pack
Admin Dashboard using WordPress Mobile Pack
As you can see, WordPress Mobile Pack gives you a simple theme for the blog design for visitors as well as the WordPress dashboard for the administrator. The simple dashboard allow you to edit and add new posts, moderate comments, and modify basic WordPress settings.
WPtouch iPhone Theme – Feature Rich
WordPress Plugin Site ~ Plugin Homepage
WPtouch iPhone Theme is the second WordPress plugin I found for easily converting WordPress sites for mobile phones. It is far more advanced in comparison to WordPress Mobile Pack. Here are some shots of Kikolani on the Droid using WPtouch iPhone Theme.
Homepage using WPtouch iPhone Theme
Customizable Menu using WPtouch iPhone Theme
Post using WPtouch iPhone Theme
Post Footer using WPtouch iPhone Theme
Post Comment Form using WPtouch iPhone Theme
As you can see, the front end design of the site has more advanced options, including a customizable menu, search feature, and the option to integrate Adsense ads, although most of mine have been Public Service Ads so far.
The post footer has arrows for previous and next post navigation, plus options to share on Twitter and bookmark on a variety of sites including Delicious, Digg, Reddit, Newsvine, Technorati, and Magnolia (hopefully something that can be modified).
The WordPress dashboard remains unchanged, so administrators have full access to all of the features, just as if they were on a regular PC.
If you do choose to go with WPtouch iPhone Theme, and you run WP Super Cache, be sure to change the settings according to this screencast by BraveNewCode so that Super Cache does not conflict with your mobile visitors’s view of your site.
Plugin Comparison Summary
I would say for those looking to get the most out of their mobile blogging experience, the WPtouch iPhone Theme plugin is the way to go. The downside of this plugin is that the advanced features may be too advanced for some phones that are not iPhones, Androids, Blackberrys, and so on. My previous phone, for example, had a full screen Internet browser, but I was never able to get into my site, front or administrative side. For older phones, the safer plugin to go with would definitely be the WordPress Mobile Pack.
Why Should You Go Mobile
Even if you don’t have a smartphone, consider visitors who might be browsing the web and find a link to your site, either off of another blog, in an email, or through their RSS subscriptions. This applies even to regular websites built in WordPress – the pages are converted into the mobile themes too, so your WordPress as CMS site could benefit as well. These plugins make it easy to make your WordPress site mobile ready.
Are You Mobile Friendly?
Do you visit blogs on your iPhone, Android, or similar device? Is your WordPress mobile friendly, and if so, what do you use? Tell us in the comments about your mobile blogging experience.
This post brought to you by Kristi Hines
Kristi Hines is creator of Kikolani which focuses on blogging tips and social networking. Connect with me on Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn.
Kristi has written 310 awesome article(s) for Kikolani.
Enjoy this post?
Use the social buttons below to add it on your favorite social sites or send it via email. Also, subscribe to posts via RSS or by email to get the latest on blogging tips, social media, and other information for successful bloggers.
Comments are Dofollow, CommentLuv, and KeywordLuv enabled. Click here to ask questions and share your opinions. The website field is optional, so you can leave it blank or use your Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn or other social network URL for your website link.
{ 34 comments… read them below or add one }
I know my site is NOT mobile friendly but I hadn’t known which plugin would be best. Thanks for the wonderful detailed comparison review!
New from Christie Be selective about your activities, but do the important ones anyway
Hi kristi,
I also use the WPtouch iPhone Theme on my blog. I think it’s a great addition to any website. Tho I’m not visiting with my iphone right now it’s nice to know if I do I will eventually see it in action.
I have never used the WordPress Mobile Pack but I might give it a try. I forget the name of the one I’m currently using for other mobile phones.
I’m not a big fan of leaving links in comments but seeing it’s so appropriate and beneficial I’m going to throw them in. They are websites where you can test your load time and page load size when using your mobile browser to see how much ti’s actually helping. it’s a pretty cool tool.
http://emulator.mtld.mobi/emulator.php
and
http://ready.mobi/launch.jsp
Thanks,
Brian
New from bbrian017 Create the perfect search engine enviroment
I don’t mind the links at all… I was trying to find a working online emulator for the iPhone and Droid originally. It’s interesting to see how these sites both come up on a non-smartphone.
Thanks to you Kristi we are using WPtouch on FamousBloggers blog, I didn’t play too much with the settings and was waiting for this post
I will checking it out latter to see if the themes but unfortunately I don’t have iPhone I am using Nokia 5800 which works just fine for me for now!
New from Hesham @ FamousBloggers Now people can search My Social Content on Google I can See my Circle
thanks already did
New from Designzzz Superb Jquery CSS Image Effects and Tooltips Tutorials
Thanks for the comparison of the two plugins. I’ve been meaning to install WPTouch for a while, but kept procrastinating. Now I will take a closer look at both, but think WPTouch looks to be the better option
New from Brian Discover Caguas Botanical Garden: A Fine Blend of History and Nature
Thanks again Kristi, for another very useful post. This was something I wanted to investigate within the next week, and your post came at a great time. I installed the WPtouch and it worked flawlessly!
New from Justin McGill@Web Marketing Theming Thursday – Joomla Business and Corporate Themes
I also use WpTouch and another mobile package so the non touch phones will work. I can get my hands on a black berry and motorola Droid and they both seem to work fine using the two mobile plugins. Greg Ellison
New from Greg Ellison New Ipad Tablet
Great post Kikolani! WPtouch iPhone Theme is very cool. For my site I’m using Mobify. What do you think?
New from Nick Conversion Optimization Is The New SEO
I am definitely going to mobilize my blog this week, mobile phones are certainly THE form of communication and information delivery these days with the advances in technology and I suspect that this will provide big perks for bloggers.
New from JR @ Internet Marketing Greatest Content Spinner Tool – Last Chance to Try for Free
I really need to get into this, I already have readers asking for it. There are so many friggin pluggins to choose from of course…
New from Dennis Edell The Time Has Come. The Deal Is Done. It’s Time To Move!!
I added the Mippin plugin to all my blogs so they are presented well on mobile devices. I thought I would get a lot more traffic by doing this but not really.
New from Steve Pay For College With Tax Credits
This is really a detailed post! We can really see clearly which is better. Mobile blogging is really in nowadays, I will definitely be trying it soon. Mobile blogging would really be of big help to people always on the go.
New from Andrew@BloggingGuide How to Create a Super Effective Squeeze Page
It was a big help to me while I was at the event on Monday. I got to check out blogs by some of the speakers before and after their sessions.
Hi!
Nice comparison – but I’d like to suggest you take a look at my mobile wordpress plugin. It’s called the Wapple Architect Mobile Plugin for Wordpress and you can download it here: http://wordpress.org/extend/plugins/wapple-architect/
It’s got everything the two plugins have that you compared but it also allows you control over your mobile SEO and gives you the ability to retain your brand identity.
If you fancy giving it a go, let me know and I’ll do my best to help – and if you want to see it in action, check out these screenshots: http://wordpress.org/extend/plugins/wapple-architect/screenshots/
I’ll definitely check it out. I have a few WordPress sites I can try it out on.
I was using Wordpress Mobile Plugin and just deactivated it. It was adding the following meta tag and I think that’s why my site wasn’t getting cached in Google but I’m not sure:
Cache-Control” content=”no-cache, must-revalidate, no-transform”
Hmmm, I haven’t seen that before, but I know the WPtouch iPhone plugin has some conflict with Super Cache, so they give you specific instructions on how to change the Super Cache settings to work with the theme. I wonder if that is a known issue with that plugin.
I use Wordpress Mobile Edition which use a Carrington-based theme. Thanks for giving me two more choice.
New from Arafat Hossain Piyada Free tool to create and edit Sony Ericsson Walkman Media Player Skins
Like Arafat, I used to be a diehard supporter of the WME plugin, though I preferred an earlier version that allowed more customization. That was until I wrote http://ariwriter.com/dumbfounded-by-customer-service/ — and ultimately shifted to the WPTouch plugin last month.
How did you embed photos from your phone? Did you take a picture of them?
New from Ari Herzog@Online Media Strategies Learning Online Marketing from McDonald’s and Coca-Cola
I have the HTC Droid, and after searching through various forums, I found some instructions on how to use the Android SDK in Windows to take screenshots of your Droid. This was the best solution because the others suggested hacking the phone.
My site is currently not mobile friendly, but I’m considering on using the WP iPhone Touch Theme. Does it look the same on all mobile phones?
Thanks for the info!
Brian
New from Brian@Tech Airlines The Instant Messaging and Social World (First Class Flyer)
“If you do choose to go with WPtouch iPhone Theme, and you run WP Super Cache, be sure to change the settings according to this screencast by BraveNewCode so that Super Cache does not conflict with your mobile visitors’s view of your site.”
Splendid! I tried a mobile theme/plug-in long ago but it clashed with SuperCache. Bookmarking your post while I try this later today on my blog
New from Michael Aulia @CravingTech WD TV Live Review
I would have a headache blogging on the phone. It takes me forever to text my friends. I can only imagine the pain of writing an article by using a phone!
-Kai Lo
Twitter @lomak1985
I’m not sure I would post a full article from my phone… I primarily use my phone access to approve comments.
I have around 30 sites, and have only recently discovered that none of them are really smartphone optimised. The smarthphones don’t seem to count for much traffic, but there is still a bit of lost revenue there..WPtouch iPhone theme seems like the way to go when trying to remedy this, so thanks for the info
New from Matt@84 Inch Shower Curtain
I don’t think they count for much traffic, but I know there have been times I’ve been out and wanted to research pricing for something I see in a store, and if I can’t get to a website to do that on, I just buy online. So that could be lost revenue, if someone could have seen your pricing is better and just waited to order it online.
Thanks for the tips Kristi….it’s amazing how much power these little Not books have. They have more memory and a quicker processor then my current laptop and cost about half as much!!
New from SEO Company Strengths of managed hosting services
I personally used the WPtouch plugin, not only because I have the iPhone but I remember reading somewhere that iPhone has the biggest ‘mobile’ search share. Either way good summary.
Very cool finds, I think I’ll have to install one or two of these.
Whenever I browse my website on my phone its really difficult, would be better if it was displayed this way.
New from Beginner DJ Excision – Shambhala 2009 Mix
I use the WPtouch on all my sites. Since I have an iPhone and haven’t been able to check it on another device, and I was curious how it looked on BBs and Droids. I love the look of the WPtouch and that it is easy to turn off the mobile view. The drop down menu is so easy to use. I have been on sites using that Wordpress Mobile Pack, and I think it isn’t as pretty or easy to navigate as WPtouch. If you can turn off mobile view, it wasn’t clear to me. I do a lot of surfing via my iPhone and am amazed how many people don’t use a mobile plugin of any kind on their Wordpress site. Nice post!
New from Melinda 4th of July Cookout
I’m a big fan of Wptouch iPhone Plugin and this is one of the essential Wordpress plugin in my plugin toolbox. Wordpress mobile pack was something I tried long time back and somehow I was not happy with the look and feel for the same…
New from Harsh Agrawal 7 Essential Wordpress Security Tips
These are very handy plugins for Wp. As an iPhone enthusiast I am very happy about them
I just learned of your information post. Ihad already looked at both of the plugins that youmention and decided that WPTouch was much better and I have been using that.
I recently paid $29 for the “Pro” version which let me create “Home Screen” icon (I’m not a “designer” so I may ask a friend who is a graphic designer to do a new one for me — maybe a sort of a “logo”) so when someone views my blog on an iPhone they can stick the icon onto one of their 11 “Home Screens” instead of just creating an ordinary bookmark.
Overall WPTouch works pretty well although it strips out some stuff (like Flash slideshows) that won’t work on the iPhone. It supposedly works on Android, Palm Pre/Pixi, and BlackBerry Storm touch screen phones. I’m not sure if I need a separate plugin to make my blog more easily readable non-touch screen, but Web-enabled phones.
{ 5 trackbacks }